North Korea executed top minister, South Korea says

  • Published
This August 28, 2016 picture released by North Korea"s official Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) on August 29, 2016 shows North Korean leader Kim Jong-Un (C) waving while attending a torchlight gala of members of the youth vanguard "Let the Youth Power March forward Following the Party!" at the May Day Stadium to mark the 9th Congress of the Kim Il Sung Socialist Youth LeagueImage source, AFP
Image caption,
Analysts say that since he came to power Kim Jong-un has not held back from purging extremely high-ranking officials suspected of disloyalty

South Korean government officials have said that North Korea executed one of its highest ranking ministers last month.

Seoul's unification ministry said Kim Yong-jin was one of Pyongyang's vice premiers and in charge of education.

Officials did not explain how they got the information. Seoul's record on reporting such developments is patchy.

In May, a North Korean military chief said to have been executed was found to be alive and attending official events.

Ri Yong-gil was widely reported to have been executed in February but when he made an appearance at North Korea's party congress it highlighted just how difficult it is to get accurate information from the North.

The unification ministry, the government department which manages relations with the North is, along with the spy agency, the South's primary source of information about Pyongyang.

The unification ministry also said a prominent minister responsible for intelligence and inter-Korean relations, Kim Yong-chol, had been sent for re-education along with another official, named as Choi Hwi, for a month in mid-July.

Might this 'execution' be confirmed ?

North Korea itself very rarely provides confirmation of such reports. The last execution Pyongyang released official information about is thought to be the notorious purge of Kim Jong-un's own uncle, Chang Song-thaek in 2013.

The strongest confirmation is usually that an executed official simply disappears from media reports.

If this report turns out to be untrue, Kim Yong-jin may well appear in public or be listed as in attendance at a major public event in Pyongyang.

Another clue to his fate might emerge if North Korea announces a replacement vice premier. Again, this does not necessarily mean he has been executed.

Ri Yong-gil was replaced as military chief but turned up months later, albeit with an apparent demotion.

Who are Kim Yong-jin and Kim Yong-chol?

Both have held high office and were mentioned in official statements and despatches from Pyongyang.

While less is known about Kim Yong-jin, Kim Yong-chol has often been seen alongside Kim Jong-un in photographs and is thought to be close to him. At the party congress in May he was named as head of national intelligence.

Experts say that North Korean officials are frequently sent for re-education, a process that can sometimes be seen as "corporate training" with some emerging from re-education with higher office while others are demoted.

Why are we hearing about this now?

The statement from the unification ministry comes a day after an unconfirmed report in a South Korean newspaper said two different high-ranking officials in the departments of education and agriculture had been executed.

It also comes shortly after the high profile defection of a UK-based North Korean diplomat to Seoul.

It is clear that there are reasons to be insecure at the top of North Korea's political establishment - Kim Jong-un went through four defence ministers in four years.

If Mr Kim's execution is confirmed, it would be just the latest in a series of purges and executions of top officials that Kim Jong-un has enacted since he came to power in 2011.